Completely agree with Neil, other than the fact that I still like GB enough to keep my Premium. Medieval Madness is probably the most accessible pin out there, and I’d argue it’s pretty much the perfect first pin if you have the budget for one. It was the second machine we ever bought around 18 years ago, and it would be the very last machine to leave. Guests also love it.
JP2 is one of the most frustrating machines I’ve ever owned. Total dream theme and I loved it at first, but as time went on it just became less and less fun to play. It’s incredibly unforgiving, and unless you’re a good player you aren’t going to see much of the game. It‘s also been very unpopular with friends.
I’d echo the advice re getting a modern Stern (or Medieval Madness Remake) if you have to get machines upstairs. They’re lighter than other machines, and it’s much easier to remove the back box and get the playfield out. Don’t even consider a Jersey Jack or wide body WMS. I once helped get a Twilight Zone up a staircase and it was a nightmare.
I’ve just moved around 90 mins south of you. My machines are being stored whilst I convert an outbuilding but you’d be welcome to come visit when the project is completed and the pins are moved in.
JP2 is far more frustrating than TNA. Different league entirely. Had them sitting next to each other for ages and TNA got much more play. It was also very popular with visitors.