I've been going to the shows since the first Aston Villa one that Nick Pins Anon put on.
I'll be blunt...my call is that the Pinball Party has got to the end of the line, 5 years without any recent fresh ideas (auctions, presentations, tutorials etc.) or new people coming up with different stuff means that it's got boring and it's now in decline. Andy alluded to this in one of the first sentences in at the evening meal. The fact is that Andy puts in a great effort, but he can't be expected to run the UK pinball world on his own.
The tournaments suffer the same. (Although one can't argue that they're not popular, with increasing numbers of participants every year!) Nonetheless, I believe they need a refresh, perhaps new formats, different venue/rooms, multiple days, there are lots of things that stop other nations players coming to the UK tournaments. One of the major complaints is that you get to play only 6 +1 machines to qualify, it has been pointed out many times that it's not that good value. One might suggest that it's the social aspects and not just the raw playing that makes a tournament, but they have a point. Also, I hate tournament machine queuing, the token system that somebody mentioned in another post, was used at the EPC in Spain, that would work.
My experiences this year was that:
- The hotel is starting to look a bit old.
- The meal was shockingly poor and bad value. Just ordering in lots of pizza's isn't the answer though, Andy needs to make money from the meal, as part of the costs for running the event. Barry Oursler flights aren't cheap.
- Barry's presentation needed "some work". He's a lovely bloke (especially as I took a fiver off him at Poker on Friday night), but he's not a born-showman and he needed to provide material.
- The number of machines was significantly down (20%?) and there were no other events (e.g. video games people) in the outside rooms.
- I don't think machine hogging was as bad as I've seen in the past, but that was probably due to there being significantly fewer people attending.
- Electrics were well taken care of as always, by those unsung electrics heroes, thanks guys.
- Thanks also to everyone who bought machine(s), you rock!
- Game selection I actually thought was OK, quite a good variety, but then again, when I remember back to Aston Villa with it's 170 machines + some vids...
5 or 6 years ago, the UK Pinball Show/Party was the only event in the UK and everyone was jumping on-board. Now there are several other top events that are taking up people's bandwidth and commitment. I think we'd be better off if Andy stepped back early and said "No more Party", and used his resources to support other people's events, perhaps as a vendor/sponsor. Whether someone else would take up the gauntlet or not to run a show, I don't know. But I don't think it really matters, it's not like there are no alternatives.
As great oaks fall, other acorns spring up in it's place. (But ideally not-for-profit and not at the Daventry hotel...Wicksteed Park again, perhaps?
)
And where would that leave the tournaments.... I wonder...