I disliked my favourite pin of all time the first two times I played it. Same with turtles, I'd not have considered it and didn't like it the first week of owning. Now I love it!
Same with music, I find the best albums are the ones that take time to grow
I’m pretty systematic about exploring pins. I started by trying to play the physical version of every pin I enjoyed on the Williams App - I’m still trying to find a Hurricane on public display. Then, I tried finding my favourite pins on Pinball Arcade which was, admittedly, mostly about playing Ghostbusters, Genie and Spirit (as a substitute for Black Hole). Then, when I saw people hyping up the modern Sterns, I had a ‘modern Stern’ phase followed by an ‘early SS’ period. I’ve also had a ‘find an EM phase’ and a ‘watching all-time-top-10-and-pinball-history-videos and playing everything’ phase.
I often write off pins due to theme. Otherwise, I’ve usually played each pin at least five times. If something has a good reputation on Pinside and I don’t engage with it, I’ll make an effort to play it more than five incase I’m missing something. If I like something after the first five plays, I will sometimes get really into it and play it for ages. I think I’ve probably played TNA for up to an hour at a time.