EVERY single Lyman pin for years was awful for up to 18 months after release, goback and read the RGP and Pinside threads about how bad they were.
Spider-Man - no wizard or mini wizard mode for ages (at one point you could get to Super Hero and NOTHING happened)
AC/DC - One of the sales features of the Prem/LE was the RGB lighting, took almost a year for them to be anything but white, sadly unfinished but still great
Metallica - Mystery wasn't (for almost a year) it was 500k and no wizard modes either, or band member modes
TWD - Amassive turd for over a year (PH had 8 pre-orders and almost every single person backed out, he had LE's for over a year), then horde and LMS were added and the game changed overnight
B66 - Everyone knows how bad this was for over a year
Elvira - It wasn't awful but it wasn't great either until about a year after release
Lonnie gets a bad rep. He gets most stuff done, he may not have the polish or ingenuity of Lyman but a lot of his games are decent enough. The difference with Lyman was that he seemed to really care/have pride in his work. To other's, it's just a job