Reading on pinside. They say the game doesn’t have many shots and that the ruleset is not very immersive with no real story. Early days on code though.
There’s one angry guy on Pinside who keeps contributing to the EJ thread because he lost money on Godfather. He keeps arguing with people who think their CE will be worth $35k in a few years’ time (and also need to give their head a wobble IMO). There's also a bunch of people who think Stern/JJP are an either/or option.
I borrowed an EJ PE for a month and now have one on order. Layout-wise, it’s a similar deal to Star Trek and Star Wars (same designer), but - in my opinion - slightly better with a more interesting focus on the upper flipper (the same thing that, in my opinion, makes Funhouse so good). There’s no story because it’s a music pin. The code reminds me of how Metallica is played by the average player, i.e. shoot a bunch of flowy shots to qualify a multiball/mini-wizard mode, rinse and move to the next multiball/mini-wizard mode, but with bells on because there are timed modes on the Rock-a-Box, and you can qualify several things at once.
It doesn’t have the ruleset of Jaws, Godzilla or JP2 - it’s doing something different. It’s not focused on timed modes, but is more a modern, complex version of something like Creech, where you’re shooting to get a multiball, but with far more multiballs and mini-modes than Creech. Someone who really doesn’t like older pins due to the code, and only wants to play Spike 2s, won’t like it because it’s not narrative-based. The player isn’t Elton, isn’t doing anything to advance a story, and just gets a score at the end. It’s not as multiball-heavy as Guns n’ Roses on factory settings, but reminds me a bit of Guns ‘n Roses on ‘tournament’ configuration where you’ve got to do a lot of stuff to get to the multiballs.
A bunch of people on Pinside claimed it was super-easy, but a bunch of people on Pinside make similar claims about literally every pin. When I've queried this, they always say “but the pin plays different at home to tournament”, which I assume means “if I set it up with at least 5 balls, outlane posts at max, and the slope of a Dutch polder, I can get to the wizard mode sometimes”. I'm not going to claim to be a great player, but if 'getting bored' of Stern Godzilla because you finished it was a regular occurrence, the super-amazing tournament players we have here in the UK may as well give up. I’ve had EJ in a small tournament and the players we had didn’t get anywhere near ‘finishing it’. I think some people treat modern pins like Baldur’s Gate 3 and want to play through them on easy in ‘story mode’, which is all good - because it’s their machine - but it doesn’t mean everyone sees pinball that way.
I've always fancied a JJP, but they've never crossed the threshold for ownership. I've always enjoyed Steve Ritchie games, but not enough to cross the threshold for ownership. The combination of JJP and Steve Ritchie just worked for me, and it survived a month played daily in our collection.