Yes ! I love a good themed X vs Y question
I have owned both -
BSD stayed longer and I would def have one again, I keep half an eye out for one. TFTC was fun , def a decent DE title but doubt I would ever have one again. They both have pros and cons but I'm calling
BSD as the 'better' game.
For atmosphere and down right creepiness you can't beat
BSD. I'm a fan of the film too so that always helps. There were late nights playing it alone in the Shack I freaked myself out and would sprint back up to the house, double bolting the door behind me
TFTC is way more comic book, light hearted horror, with the usual Data East barrage of music and sounds. Talking of sounds ....oh god the cackling on Crypt ! And the noise of the guillotines are lodged in my head forever.
As others noted rules wise Crypt is your standard mid 90s complete loads of modes for a Wizard mode.
BSD is kind of modeless really and is very much multiball stacking - which is both its strength as a great game and its weakness - it can feel all or nothing sometimes, yet super rewarding when its ALL ! Always found it harder trying to explain the rules to someone with
BSD, its not as obvious what to do and there are some important things to get yr head round like the Bats bonus.
Worth noting that since I had TFTC Chad has done one of his wonderful DE code updates - which I'm sure addresses any issues ,and going on all his other updates improves the game.
https://www.pinballcode.com/tftc4